Skip to main content

Left, Right, or Straight_6 Analysis

 

Left, Right, or Straight_6 Analysis

Leg 18 from the ultra-long course of the Norwegian Championship on 12 May 2019 (in class M19-20)

Upon a quick review of the GPS tracks, it appears that the right route falls significantly behind the left route, despite its brief extension and the majority being on a well-maintained road.



This appears to be a cleverly devised trap by the course setter, resulting in a potential loss of at least one minute for those who opted for the seemingly advantageous larger road without considering the challenges of the subsequent section leading to the control point.

Among those with GPS trackers, 9 out of 10 participants opted for the left route.



Let's delve deeper into these two routes and examine the competitors' outcomes more thoroughly.

Leg 18 spans approximately 1700 meters, with KP18 situated 25 meters higher than KP17. This suggests that it was logical for competitors to choose a route that involved less descent to minimize the subsequent climb.

The right route covers 1980 meters, featuring an initially easy stretch on a broad forest road with a descent of 75 meters. However, a steep ascent on a rocky hill follows 65 meters after the road, just before approaching the control point.

The left route is about 2250 meters, mostly on a trail, albeit one on frequently boggy terrain.

In the initial part of this leg, there is a 50-meter descent, followed by a gradual 25-meter climb along the trail, leading to the approach to control 18 without gaining altitude along the slope.


The winner, Kasper Fosser, exhibited superior speed throughout the course and on this particular leg, winning by 54 seconds over the competitor who chose the same route and by 1.31 over the one who took the right-hand route.

However, when comparing Jørgen Baklid's time (the sole participant who took the right route) with competitors of similar running speeds, it becomes evident that the left and right routes yield comparable results.

Analysing the splits of the 3rd and 4th placed competitors on the course (Jørgen Baklid and Sander Arntzen), who had similar overall times and comparable performances on the legs leading to leg 18 ( Particularly noteworthy is their performance on run 10-11, where both took around 12 minutes),  reveals interesting insights. Their time on the leg 18 is roughly equal. 

An intriguing speed statistic emerged at leg 18, showcasing an 18-minute per km hill climb on the right route, a pace three times slower than the section with a gentle climb on the left route.


Kasper Fosser maintained an impressive pace of 4.30 min/km.

Sander Arntzen, finishing in 4th place on the same right-hand route, had a pace of 5.14 min/km.

The second-place runner on the leg and the entire course, Lukas Liland, achieved a pace of 4.48 min/km. However, it seems he didn't execute the route flawlessly and could have narrowed the gap to Kasper on this leg.

sources: http://3drerun.worldofo.com/2d/?lidstr=20190512ultraH1920

http://obasen.orientering.se/winsplits/online/en/default.asp?page=table&databaseId=62449&categoryId=4

Aleksandr Alekseyonok, January 31, 2024

My book on orienteering for advanced athletes

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

  Case Study #4 Case: You ran onto a narrow ride slightly below its end and are unsure which of several similar rides you are on.   Solution: In this situation, the relief profile can assist us. Even if the rides themselves appear similar, the relief profile along each ride differs , providing valuable clues for accurate positioning. This approach is discussed in Chapter 3 ( Using All the Indicators for Confident Positioning ) of the book Planning Reliable Routes . It demonstrates that relief can be used not only when we are uncertain about our current location , but also proactively during route planning . By analysing the map in advance, we can identify segments where linear features intersect with relief forms , creating distinct and easily recognisable points. These can serve as reliable positioning features . Additionally, flat areas and transitions between slopes and level terrain can also support effective location verification. (Example taken from my book Plann...
Post a Comment
Read more

New o-book is coming this fall!

  New O-Book Coming This Fall! Confident Orienteering: A Systematic Approach to Minimising Errors Book 1: Fundamentals was released in October 2023 and has already been translated into seven languages , alongside the original English edition. With 8 chapters and 140 pages, it introduced the core concepts of the author's navigation system — and I’m still amazed at how warmly it was received by orienteers around the world. 🌍 As we continued working on the next part of this practical guide, it became clear that the project had grown into something much bigger — not least because of the sheer number of examples and illustrations included throughout (around 250 in total!). To make the material easier to absorb, we’re now leaning towards splitting it into two volumes , each with its own clear focus. This isn’t a final decision yet, and even the titles below are working titles — but right now, this structure feels like the most reader-friendly option: 📖 Book 2 (working title...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Road to JWOC 2026, #2 (Long Distance)

  The Road to JWOC 2026, #2 (Long Distance) Short  Leg 1: what to do In the previous post in this series, we identified—based on the terrain characteristics and extensive experience from many previous competitions in this area—that a short first leg with complex navigation is highly likely. In this post, we focus on what exactly to do in such a situation. Let us begin by explaining why we are specifically discussing short first legs . If the first leg is longer , it will most likely intersect paths , as this terrain is full of paths of different types . In that case, an athlete has several safety options : – choosing a detour along paths; – or navigating less precisely on a bearing , deliberately aiming off early to hit a path and then restoring exact position while running along it. https://www.livelox.com/Viewer/JVM-test-lang/D20?classId=392774&live=false&tab=player In such scenarios, the initial nervousness and uncertainty at the beginning of the co...
Post a Comment
Read more